
Where you live in Florida moves your premium by 34% — Miami-Dade runs 34% above Orlando for the same driver, same coverage. And which company you pick matters even more: the cheapest vs. priciest insurers differ by 6.1× for identical coverage on the same driver. Florida is the most expensive state in the country for car insurance — and the gap between the cheapest and priciest company is the widest we have measured in any state so far.
By Roland Wang, Founder of CubePower · Data as of October 2026 · Last updated November 2026 · Built from official Florida Office of Insurance Regulation (FLOIR) CHOICES rate data
Index = median company premium in the county ÷ median company premium in Orange County (Orlando), same driver profile (single female, 25, one violation + one no-fault accident, all coverages). Median $ = median annual premium across the 21 companies in that county.
| County | Index | vs Orlando | Median premium / yr |
|---|---|---|---|
| Miami-Dade | 134 | +34% | $6,708 |
| Broward (Fort Lauderdale) | 130 | +30% | $6,501 |
| Hillsborough (Tampa) | 122 | +22% | $6,081 |
| Orange (Orlando) | 100 | baseline | $4,990 |

The four counties in the state comparison are all large metros, so this index cannot show the full north-south gap. An independent read points the same way, wider: MoneyGeek's 20-city table puts Miami at $268 a month and Gainesville at $139 — nearly double. Miami is expensive on every ranking; Orlando is cheap on every ranking. And the spread inside a single county is large too: in Miami-Dade, the cheapest company on this profile charges $2,920 a year while the priciest charges $18,752 — a 6.4× gap in one county.
Factor = median(company premium ÷ county market median) across the four counties. Below 1.00 = cheaper than the typical company. Median $ = median of the company's four county premiums. Same driver profile as above.
| Company | Price factor | Median premium / yr |
|---|---|---|
| The Standard Fire Insurance Co. | 0.390× | $2,372 |
| USAA | 0.500× | $3,110 |
| USAA General Indemnity | 0.570× | $3,558 |
| USAA Casualty | 0.571× | $3,590 |
| Security National | 0.580× | $3,542 |
| Florida Farm Bureau Casualty | 0.677× | $4,190 |
| Allstate North American | 0.689× | $4,355 |
| GEICO Choice | 0.814× | $4,969 |
| Allstate Insurance Co. | 0.856× | $5,156 |
| Allstate Fire and Casualty | 0.868× | $5,372 |
Two footnotes from the data itself are worth knowing. The Standard Fire Insurance Company prices at 0.390× — less than half the market median — but it is a Travelers-group company that does not quote every driver; the cheapest widely available option on this profile is USAA at 0.500×, and USAA is limited to the military community. And the three USAA entities in the data (USAA, USAA General Indemnity, USAA Casualty) all sit in the cheapest five — the group is consistently cheap here, not cheap through one subsidiary. Florida Farm Bureau (0.677×) is the next-cheapest widely available name — its policies are sold to Farm Bureau members, and membership is open to the public.
Same profile, same method. The priciest company prices at more than six times the cheapest for identical coverage.
| Company | Price factor | Median premium / yr |
|---|---|---|
| Peak Property and Casualty | 2.377× | $14,945 |
| Auto Club Insurance Co. of Florida (AAA) | 1.777× | $11,317 |
| Infinity Auto | 1.726× | $10,209 |
| Direct General | 1.612× | $9,902 |
| United Automobile | 1.589× | $9,098 |
Peak Property and Casualty at 2.377× is the outlier of the whole index — its median of $14,945 a year is more than double the market median in every county, reaching $18,752 in Miami-Dade. The rest of the priciest five cluster between 1.589× and 1.777×. Note that United Automobile's Hillsborough premium ($17,730) is the single highest county quote in the data, while its other three counties run $8,528 to $9,552 — a reminder that a company can be mid-priced in three counties and the most expensive in the fourth.
Factor = median(company premium ÷ county market median) across the four counties; median $ = median of the company's four county premiums. GEICO and Allstate each write in Florida through several entities, and the entities price very differently — the name on the ad is not the price you get.
| Brand | Price factor | Median premium / yr |
|---|---|---|
| The Standard Fire (Travelers group) | 0.390× | $2,372 |
| USAA | 0.500× | $3,110 |
| Allstate North American | 0.689× | $4,355 |
| GEICO Choice | 0.814× | $4,969 |
| Allstate Insurance Co. | 0.856× | $5,156 |
| GEICO Advantage | 1.000× | $6,291 |
| GEICO Indemnity | 1.105× | $6,894 |
| Progressive Select | 1.246× | $7,680 |
| Progressive American | 1.554× | $9,428 |
| Auto Club Insurance Co. of Florida (AAA) | 1.777× | $11,317 |
GEICO Advantage, at exactly 1.000×, is the median company in this data — its four county premiums are the market medians themselves. But GEICO's other entities range from 0.814× (Choice) to 1.117× (Casualty), so two GEICO customers on the same profile can pay prices 37% apart depending on which entity underwrites them. The same holds for Allstate: its three entities span 0.689× to 0.868×, and for Progressive, whose two entities span 1.246× to 1.554×. One honest gap in this index: State Farm, Travelers, Farmers, and Nationwide are not among the 21 companies in the FLOIR sample, so this ranking says nothing about them — a company missing from the table is not a company that is expensive or cheap, only a company this data does not cover.
Published averages agree on the ranking even though they use different profiles. Insurance.com puts Florida average full coverage at $3,852 a year; autoinsurance.com puts it at $3,672 a year — in both cases the highest of any state. Four forces are usually cited, and all four are visible in the public record:
None of this means a Florida driver is stuck with the state average. The company spread in this index — 6.1× from cheapest to priciest — is larger than the county spread, larger than the uninsured-driver effect, and larger than any single cost driver above. Shopping the company is the one lever entirely in the driver's hands.
If you searched for Florida car insurance this year, you may have read that the state repealed PIP — its no-fault personal injury protection — effective July 1, 2026, and switched to an at-fault system with mandatory bodily injury coverage. That claim is wrong, and it is worth correcting because several insurance guides still carry it.
The two bills that would have ended the no-fault system in the 2026 regular session — Senate Bill 522 and House Bill 769 — both died in committee on March 13, 2026, the day the session adjourned, without a floor vote in either chamber. No repeal bill reached the governor in 2026. The July 1, 2026 date came from a different bill, HB 1181, filed in the 2025 session — which was withdrawn from consideration on May 3, 2025. The closest Florida has come was 2021, when a repeal bill (SB 54) passed both chambers and was vetoed by the governor.
As of today, the no-fault law (Florida Statute 627.736) is still in force: $10,000 of PIP and $10,000 of property damage liability are still required to register a vehicle, the 14-day treatment deadline still applies, and bodily injury liability is still not required for most drivers. A repeal would change the numbers in this index — mandatory bodily injury coverage would replace PIP — but until a bill actually becomes law, the system described here is the system Florida drivers buy into.
To register a vehicle in Florida you must carry $10,000 of Personal Injury Protection (PIP) and $10,000 of property damage liability. Florida is unusual in that bodily injury liability is not required for most drivers. Minimum coverage pays for your own injuries (PIP) and damage you cause to others' property; it does not cover damage to your own car or injuries you cause to other people.
Roland Wang is the founder of CubePower. He built CubePower's auto insurance estimator and calibrated it against the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation's published rate comparison data. This article is based on that public data. It is educational research, not an insurance quote or advice — your actual premium depends on your driver profile, vehicle, and ZIP code.
This index uses one standard driver profile. Your rate depends on your car, driving history, and coverage choices — run the free CubePower estimator for a personalized estimate in under a minute.