2026 Maryland Auto Insurance Price Index

Vista aérea de un vecindario suburbano con casas y calles
Baltimore is the priciest area in the Maryland Insurance Administration rate comparison — nearly double Frederick.

Where you live in Maryland moves your premium by 92% — Baltimore runs 92% above Frederick for the same driver, same coverage. And which company you pick matters even more: the cheapest vs. priciest insurers differ by 9.2× for identical coverage on the same driver. That is the widest company spread we have measured in any state so far — wider than Florida's 6.1× and California's 3.6×.

By Roland Wang, Founder of CubePower · Data as of October 2026 · Last updated November 2026 · Built from the official Maryland Insurance Administration (MIA) Auto Insurance Comparison Guide, rates effective August 1, 2026

92%
Baltimore vs. Frederick, same driver
9.2×
Cheapest vs. priciest insurer, same driver
53
Companies in the MIA comparison, 29 ZIP codes

Key findings

Regional price index (Baltimore = 100)

Index = territory factor relative to Baltimore city (ZIP prefix 212), from the MIA guide's 29 ZIP codes. The reference ZIP is Baltimore 21218 = 1.00; the 212 prefix as a whole is 0.96.

Baltimore city (212)100 (baseline)
DC suburbs — Prince George's (207)84 (-16%)
Baltimore suburbs (211)73 (-27%)
Montgomery County (209)67 (-33%)
Baltimore suburbs (210)64 (-36%)
Cecil / northeast (219)64 (-36%)
Southern Maryland (206)63 (-37%)
Montgomery County (208)59 (-41%)
Annapolis (214)59 (-41%)
Western Maryland (215)55 (-45%)
Eastern Shore (216 / 218)54 (-46%)
Frederick (217)52 (-48%)
RegionIndexvs Baltimore
Baltimore city (212)100baseline
DC suburbs — Prince George's (207)84-16%
Baltimore suburbs (211)73-27%
Montgomery County (209)67-33%
Baltimore suburbs (210)64-36%
Cecil / northeast (219)64-36%
Southern Maryland (206)63-37%
Montgomery County (208)59-41%
Annapolis (214)59-41%
Western Maryland (215)55-45%
Eastern Shore (216 / 218)54-46%
Frederick (217)52-48%

The gap is a city-versus-countryside story. Baltimore and the D.C. suburbs sit at the top; the rural west and the Eastern Shore sit at the bottom, at about half Baltimore's price. An independent read points the same way: MoneyGeek puts Baltimore full coverage at $248 a month versus $113 in Hagerstown — a $1,620-a-year gap between two Maryland cities. And the spread inside a single area is large too: the company spread in this index (9.2×) is far larger than the regional spread (1.9×), so shopping the company matters more than moving.

Cheapest companies in Maryland (relative to market median)

Factor = median(company premium ÷ market median) across the 29 ZIP codes and 22 scenarios in the MIA guide. Below 1.00 = cheaper than the typical company.

Branch Insurance Exchange0.355×
Progressive Select Insurance Co.0.502×
Progressive Specialty Insurance Co.0.602×
GEICO Advantage Co.0.652×
CSAA General Insurance Co.0.685×
American Economy Insurance Co.0.701×
State Farm Mutual Ins. Co.0.701×
Farmers Insurance Exchange0.710×
United Services Automobile Association0.727×
Erie Insurance Exchange0.738×
CompanyPrice factor
Branch Insurance Exchange0.355×
Progressive Select Insurance Co.0.502×
Progressive Specialty Insurance Co.0.602×
GEICO Advantage Co.0.652×
CSAA General Insurance Co.0.685×
American Economy Insurance Co.0.701×
State Farm Mutual Ins. Co.0.701×
Farmers Insurance Exchange0.710×
United Services Automobile Association0.727×
Erie Insurance Exchange0.738×

Two footnotes from the data itself are worth knowing. Branch Insurance Exchange prices at 0.355× — about a third of the market median — but it is a small exchange, not a household name; the cheapest widely available options on this profile are Progressive Select at 0.502× and GEICO Advantage at 0.652×. And the three USAA entities in the data (the Association itself at 0.727×, plus Casualty at 0.776× and General Indemnity at 0.857×) all sit in the cheaper half — the group is consistently cheap here, not cheap through one subsidiary.

Priciest companies in Maryland

Same guide, same method. The priciest company prices at more than nine times the cheapest for identical coverage.

Dairyland Insurance Co.3.256×
Maryland Auto Insurance Fund2.393×
Liberty Mutual Insurance Co.2.192×
Elephant Insurance Co.2.119×
Liberty Mutual Personal Insurance Co.1.976×
CompanyPrice factor
Dairyland Insurance Co.3.256×
Maryland Auto Insurance Fund2.393×
Liberty Mutual Insurance Co.2.192×
Elephant Insurance Co.2.119×
Liberty Mutual Personal Insurance Co.1.976×

Dairyland at 3.256× is the outlier of the whole index — more than three times the market median. The Maryland Auto Insurance Fund at 2.393× is the state's insurer of last resort, so its price reflects the drivers it is required to take. Liberty Mutual's two entities (2.192× and 1.976×) are both in the priciest five, which is unusual for a major national brand — in most states Liberty Mutual prices near the middle. One honest gap in this index: Nationwide is not among the 53 companies in the MIA sample, so this ranking says nothing about it — a company missing from the table is not a company that is expensive or cheap, only a company this data does not cover.

Anuncio

Where the big names rank

Factor = median(company premium ÷ market median) across the 29 ZIP codes and 22 scenarios in the MIA guide. GEICO, Progressive, State Farm, USAA, and Farmers each write in Maryland through several entities, and the entities price very differently — the name on the ad is not the price you get.

BrandPrice factor
Progressive Select0.502×
Progressive Specialty0.602×
GEICO Advantage0.652×
State Farm Mutual0.701×
Farmers Insurance Exchange0.710×
USAA (United Services Automobile Assn.)0.727×
Erie Insurance Exchange0.738×
USAA Casualty0.776×
USAA General Indemnity0.857×
Travelers Property Casualty0.929×
Allstate Indemnity1.000×
American Family Connect1.012×
State Farm Fire & Casualty1.277×
Liberty Mutual Insurance Co.2.192×

Allstate Indemnity, at exactly 1.000×, sits effectively at the market median (the median of the 53 companies is 1.005×). The widest within-brand gap belongs to State Farm: its Mutual company (0.701×) and its Fire & Casualty company (1.277×) sit 82% apart. Progressive's two entities span 0.502× to 0.602×, and USAA's three span 0.727× to 0.857× — both groups are cheap across every entity, which is rarer than it sounds. Erie (0.738×), a regional carrier strong in the mid-Atlantic, prices in the cheapest ten, ahead of every national brand except Progressive Select and GEICO Advantage.

What Maryland requires — and why it costs what it does

Maryland requires more coverage than most states. The minimum is liability of $30,000 per person and $60,000 per accident for bodily injury plus $15,000 for property damage (30/60/15), with uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage in the same amounts — and $2,500 of personal injury protection (PIP) per accident, which can be waived in writing. The mandatory uninsured-motorist and PIP layers are part of why Maryland's minimum coverage costs more than in states that require liability alone.

Published averages put Maryland near the national middle, but they disagree on the level because they use different profiles: MoneyGeek puts full coverage at $150 a month ($1,802 a year), while a Quadrant-based read of filed rates puts it at $197 a month ($2,362 a year) for a 40-year-old clean-record driver. The relativities in this index are more stable than any single average: whichever profile you pick, Baltimore costs about twice Frederick, and the cheapest company costs about a ninth of the priciest.

None of this means a Maryland driver is stuck with the state average. The company spread in this index — 9.2× from cheapest to priciest — is larger than the regional spread, larger than the Baltimore–Frederick gap, and larger than any single cost driver above. Shopping the company is the one lever entirely in the driver's hands.

Methodology

Preguntas frecuentes

Maryland requires liability coverage of at least $30,000 per person and $60,000 per accident for bodily injury, and $15,000 per accident for property damage (30/60/15). Uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage in the same amounts is also required, as is $2,500 of personal injury protection (PIP) per accident — PIP can be waived in writing.

About the author

Roland Wang is the founder of CubePower. He built CubePower's auto insurance estimator and calibrated it against the Maryland Insurance Administration's published rate comparison data. This article is based on that public data. It is educational research, not an insurance quote or advice — your actual premium depends on your driver profile, vehicle, and ZIP code.

Get your personalized estimate

This index uses the state comparison guide's scenarios. Your rate depends on your car, driving history, and coverage choices — run the free CubePower estimator for a personalized estimate in under a minute.