Where you live in Texas moves your premium by 41% — and which company you pick matters even more: the cheapest vs. priciest insurers differ by 8.7× for identical coverage on the same driver.
Published by CubePower · Data as of October 2026 · Built from official Texas Department of Insurance rate data
Key findings
Where you live moves your premium by 41%. For the same driver profile, Houston prices run 24% above Austin; El Paso runs 12% below. The Houston–El Paso gap is the widest among the five metros tracked.
Which company you pick matters even more. Across 33 companies, the priciest prices at 4.09× the market median while the cheapest prices at 0.47× — an 8.7× spread for identical coverage on the same driver.
The cheapest recognizable names are USAA (0.55× median) and Progressive County Mutual (0.56× median). Several Texas county mutuals price below the big national brands, but availability varies by eligibility.
Dallas sits 18% above Austin; San Antonio 3% below. The price ranking of the five metros: Houston > Dallas > Austin > San Antonio > El Paso.
City price index (Austin = 100)
Index = median company premium in metro ÷ median company premium in Austin, same driver profile.
Metro
Index
vs Austin
Houston
124
+24%
Dallas
118
+18%
Austin
100
baseline
San Antonio
97
−3%
El Paso
88
−12%
Cheapest companies in Texas (relative to market median)
Factor = median(company premium ÷ market median) across the five metros. Below 1.00 = cheaper than the typical company.
Company
Price factor
Farmers Texas County Mutual
0.47×
USAA (United Services Automobile Assn)
0.55×
Progressive County Mutual
0.56×
USAA Casualty Insurance Co.
0.62×
Progressive County Mutual – Direct
0.66×
Priciest companies in Texas
Company
Price factor
Safeco General Agency
2.45×
Amica Property and Casualty
2.46×
Sentinel Insurance Co. Ltd.
2.65×
Dairyland County Mutual
2.80×
Encompass Independent
4.09×
Anuncio
Methodology
Source: Texas Department of Insurance HelpInsure rate comparison tool, retrieved October 5, 2026 — 5 metro areas × 33 companies.
Driver profile: male, age 25–64, single, 50/100/50 liability limits (the DOI's standard comparison scenario).
What the numbers are: relative price factors (company vs. market median), not dollar quotes. Your actual premium depends on your age, record, vehicle, credit, and ZIP.
Limitations: one standard profile; county mutuals may have membership or eligibility restrictions; factors are medians across metros and individual results vary. This is an educational index, not a rate filing.
Preguntas frecuentes
It depends heavily on where you live. For the same driver profile, Houston runs about 24% above Austin while El Paso runs about 12% below — a 41% spread between the priciest and cheapest of the five major metros, based on Texas Department of Insurance HelpInsure rate data.
Get your personalized estimate
This index uses one standard driver profile. Your rate depends on your car, driving history, and coverage choices — run the free CubePower estimator for a personalized estimate in under a minute.