2025 Arizona Auto Insurance Price Index

Aerial view of a suburban neighborhood with houses and streets
Glendale is the priciest city in the DIFI comparison — 73% above Sierra Vista for the same driver, same coverage.

Where you live in Arizona moves your premium by 73% — Glendale runs 73% above Sierra Vista for the same driver, same coverage. And which company you pick matters even more: the cheapest vs. priciest insurers differ by 6.4× for identical coverage on the same driver. That is the second-widest company spread we have measured in any state so far — behind Maryland's 9.2×, ahead of Florida's 6.1× and California's 3.6×.

By Roland Wang, Founder of CubePower · Data as of March 2025 · Last updated November 2026 · Built from the official Arizona Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions (DIFI) 2025 Premium Comparison, rates effective March 1, 2025

73%
Glendale vs. Sierra Vista, same driver
6.4×
Cheapest vs. priciest insurer, same driver
88
Companies in the DIFI comparison, 10 cities

Key findings

City price index (Phoenix = 100)

Index = territory factor relative to Phoenix = 1.00, from the DIFI comparison's 10 cities and 14 hypotheticals. Phoenix is the reference city; the other nine are priced against it.

Glendale106 (+6%)
Phoenix100 (baseline)
Mesa90 (-10%)
Scottsdale87 (-13%)
Tucson84 (-16%)
Casa Grande77 (-23%)
Yuma71 (-29%)
Nogales69 (-31%)
Flagstaff66 (-34%)
Sierra Vista61 (-39%)
CityIndexvs Phoenix
Glendale106+6%
Phoenix100baseline
Mesa90-10%
Scottsdale87-13%
Tucson84-16%
Casa Grande77-23%
Yuma71-29%
Nogales69-31%
Flagstaff66-34%
Sierra Vista61-39%

The gap is a metro-versus-outstate story. The four Valley cities — Glendale, Phoenix, Mesa, and Scottsdale — occupy the top four spots, while the border and mountain towns sit at the bottom: Sierra Vista at 61, Flagstaff at 66, Nogales at 69. Tucson, the state's second city, is the fifth-priciest at 84 — 16% below Phoenix. An independent read points the same way: MoneyGeek puts Phoenix full coverage at $181 a month versus $141 in Tucson — a $480-a-year gap between the two cities. And the spread inside a single city is large too: the company spread in this index (6.4×) is far larger than the city spread (1.7×), so shopping the company matters more than moving.

Cheapest companies in Arizona (relative to market median)

Factor = median(company premium ÷ market median) across the 10 cities and 14 hypotheticals in the DIFI comparison. Below 1.00 = cheaper than the typical company.

Progressive Preferred Insurance Co.0.331×
Progressive Advanced Insurance Co.0.332×
State National Insurance Co.0.439×
Bristol West Insurance Co.0.440×
Vault Reciprocal Exchange0.465×
GEICO Choice Insurance Co.0.471×
Teachers Insurance Co.0.474×
CSAA General Insurance Co.0.491×
USAA General Indemnity Co.0.494×
USAA Casualty Insurance Co.0.504×
CompanyPrice factor
Progressive Preferred Insurance Co.0.331×
Progressive Advanced Insurance Co.0.332×
State National Insurance Co.0.439×
Bristol West Insurance Co.0.440×
Vault Reciprocal Exchange0.465×
GEICO Choice Insurance Co.0.471×
Teachers Insurance Co.0.474×
CSAA General Insurance Co.0.491×
USAA General Indemnity Co.0.494×
USAA Casualty Insurance Co.0.504×

Two footnotes from the data itself are worth knowing. The two Progressive entities are effectively tied at the bottom — Preferred at 0.331× and Advanced at 0.332× — so unlike in other states, there is no wrong Progressive door to walk through here. And the two USAA entities in the data (General Indemnity at 0.494× and Casualty at 0.504×) both sit in the cheapest ten — the group is consistently cheap here, not cheap through one subsidiary. Every company in this top ten is priced on the full 140 rate cells, so the ranking is not a small-sample artifact.

Priciest companies in Arizona

Same comparison, same method. The priciest company prices at more than six times the cheapest for identical coverage.

Chubb group (6 entities, tied)2.106×
Encompass Property and Casualty Co.2.102×
Infinity Casualty Insurance Co.2.011×
Economy Premier Assurance Co.1.715×
Allstate Indemnity Co.1.639×
CompanyPrice factor
Chubb group (6 entities, tied)2.106×
Encompass Property and Casualty Co.2.102×
Infinity Casualty Insurance Co.2.011×
Economy Premier Assurance Co.1.715×
Allstate Indemnity Co.1.639×

The six Chubb-group entities — Chubb National, Federal, Great Northern, Pacific Indemnity, Vigilant, and Executive Risk Indemnity — all price at exactly 2.106×, because the group files the same rates through each entity; the table above lists them as one tied group. Encompass at 2.102× is essentially at the same level. One honest gap in this index: Travelers is not among the 88 companies in the DIFI sample, so this ranking says nothing about it — and outside this data Travelers is often cited as Arizona's cheapest full-coverage option, so its absence is a real hole. A company missing from the table is not a company that is expensive or cheap, only a company this data does not cover.

Advertisement

Where the big names rank

Factor = median(company premium ÷ market median) across the 10 cities and 14 hypotheticals in the DIFI comparison. GEICO, Progressive, Allstate, USAA, and Liberty Mutual each write in Arizona through several entities, and the entities price very differently — the name on the ad is not the price you get.

BrandPrice factor
Progressive Preferred0.331×
Progressive Advanced0.332×
GEICO Choice0.471×
CSAA General (AAA)0.491×
USAA General Indemnity0.494×
USAA Casualty0.504×
GEICO Secure0.537×
Farmers Insurance Exchange0.696×
American Family Insurance Co.0.805×
State Farm Fire & Casualty0.812×
Allstate North American0.819×
Allstate Fire & Casualty0.938×
Liberty Mutual Personal Insurance Co.1.049×
Nationwide General Insurance Co.1.108×
Liberty Mutual Insurance Co.1.139×
Amica Mutual Insurance Co.1.243×
Allstate Indemnity1.639×

The median company in the comparison prices at 1.019× — so State Farm Fire & Casualty at 0.812× and Farmers at 0.696× are both meaningfully below the typical Arizona insurer, while Nationwide General at 1.108× and Liberty Mutual at 1.139× sit just above it. The widest within-brand gap belongs to Allstate: its North American company (0.819×) and its Fire & Casualty company (0.938×) are both below the median, while its Indemnity company (1.639×) sits 75% above its Fire & Casualty sibling. Progressive's two entities are nearly identical (0.331× vs. 0.332×), and GEICO's two span 0.471× to 0.537× — both groups are cheap across every entity, which is rarer than it sounds.

What Arizona requires — and why it costs what it does

Arizona requires less coverage than most states. The minimum is liability of $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident for bodily injury plus $15,000 for property damage (25/50/15) — raised from 15/30/10 on July 1, 2020. Uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage must be offered in the same amounts, but you may reject it in writing, and Arizona does not require personal injury protection (PIP). The thin mandatory layer is part of why Arizona's minimum coverage is cheap — and part of why it leaves a driver exposed: the minimum pays the other driver's bills, not yours.

Published averages put Arizona near the national middle, but they disagree on the level because they use different profiles: Experian puts full coverage at $207 a month ($2,484 a year), MoneyGeek at $136 a month ($1,628 a year), and Insurify at $163 a month — a $71-a-month spread between published “averages” for the same state. The relativities in this index are more stable than any single average: whichever profile you pick, Glendale costs about three-quarters more than Sierra Vista, and the cheapest company costs about a sixth of the priciest.

None of this means an Arizona driver is stuck with the state average. The company spread in this index — 6.4× from cheapest to priciest — is larger than the city spread, larger than the Glendale–Sierra Vista gap, and larger than any single cost driver above. Shopping the company is the one lever entirely in the driver's hands.

Methodology

Frequently asked questions

Arizona requires liability coverage of at least $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident for bodily injury, and $15,000 per accident for property damage (25/50/15). Uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage must be offered in the same amounts but can be rejected in writing. Arizona does not require PIP.

About the author

Roland Wang is the founder of CubePower. He built CubePower's auto insurance estimator and calibrated it against the Arizona Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions' published rate comparison data. This article is based on that public data. It is educational research, not an insurance quote or advice — your actual premium depends on your driver profile, vehicle, and ZIP code.

Get your personalized estimate

This index uses the state comparison's hypotheticals. Your rate depends on your car, driving history, and coverage choices — run the free CubePower estimator for a personalized estimate in under a minute.