Compare Your Real Quotes
Insurers quote in different payment frequencies to make comparison hard. Enter up to 4 quotes — we'll normalize everything to annual cost and highlight the winner.

Quote 1
Quote 2
Add at least 2 quotes to compare
Enter the quotes you've received — company name, payment amount, and how often you pay. We'll do the math.
How to compare quotes fairly
- Compare identical coverage — a cheaper quote with lower limits isn't a deal.
- Watch for fees: some insurers add installment fees to monthly payments.
- Check the deductible — a $1,000 deductible quote will always look cheaper than $500.
- Ask each insurer about discounts you might qualify for before deciding.
Data & methodology
Data sources
- Your own quotes — entered manually. No external data is used.
- Payment frequency normalization factors: monthly ×12, quarterly ×4, semi-annual ×2, annual ×1.
Last updated
Normalization logic reviewed October 2026. No data updates needed — this tool works on your inputs.
Key assumptions
- Normalization is pure arithmetic — it does not account for installment fees some insurers charge.
- Quotes are assumed to be for identical coverage; comparing different coverage levels is misleading.
- Saved quotes are stored only in your browser (localStorage, 7 days) — never sent to our servers.
Worked example
Quote A: $180/month → $2,160/year. Quote B: $1,050/semi-annual → $2,100/year. Quote B is $60/year cheaper despite the higher per-payment amount — this is why normalizing to annual matters.
Frequently asked questions
Why do insurers use different payment frequencies?
Monthly quotes look smaller and harder to compare. Always normalize to annual cost — that's the number that matters. Some insurers also add $5–$10 installment fees per monthly payment.
Is the cheapest quote always the best?
Not necessarily. Check that liability limits, deductibles, and add-ons (rental, roadside) match. Also consider the insurer's claim satisfaction ratings — the cheapest company that fights every claim isn't a bargain.
Can I negotiate using a competitor's quote?
Yes. Bring the competing quote to your current insurer and ask them to match or beat it. Retention departments often have undisclosed discounts.
How many quotes should I get?
At least 3 — ideally 4–5. Price spreads of 30–50% for identical coverage are common, so each additional quote increases your chance of finding a real bargain.
Is my data saved or sent anywhere?
No. Your quotes are stored only in your browser's local storage on your device. Nothing is sent to our servers or shared.
Educational tool only — not insurance advice. Annual normalization is arithmetic; actual policy costs may include fees. Always verify final prices with the insurer.
